Pay with crypto No monthly fee Card details instantly

Chargeback Calculator: Refund or Fight?

See what a refund, a won dispute and a lost chargeback each leave you with on an order, including goods, fees and staff time. Then check your chargeback ratio against Visa and Mastercard limits.

The order
Dispute assumptions

What you end up with on this order

If the sale goes through normally—
Refund now—
Chargeback, you win—Sale kept, fee and time spent
Chargeback, you lose—Money, goods, fees and time lost

A chargeback also counts towards your monitoring ratio even if you win it. A refund issued before a dispute does not.

Chargeback ratio

Check your chargeback ratio

Card networks watch how many disputes you get compared with how many card payments you take. Enter one month of numbers.

Mastercard divides this month's chargebacks by last month's transactions; if your volume is steady, using one month is a fair estimate.

—chargeback ratio

    The real cost

    What a chargeback actually costs you

    The fee is the part merchants notice. It is rarely the biggest part.

    The sale amountTaken back from your account as soon as the dispute is opened.
    Goods and shippingUsually gone: unlike a refund, the customer rarely sends anything back.
    Processing feeThe fee on the original payment is normally not returned.
    Chargeback feeCharged per dispute, often $15 to $25 and up to $100 for high-risk accounts. Some providers add a fee to contest.
    Staff timeFinding orders, gathering evidence and writing a response, for every dispute.
    Account riskA high ratio can bring monitoring fees, higher rates, held funds or a closed merchant account.
    Decision guide

    Refund or fight the chargeback?

    When a customer complains before going to their bank, a quick refund is almost always cheaper: you lose the processing fee, but avoid the chargeback fee, the staff time and a mark against your ratio.

    Once a dispute is open, refunding no longer helps, so the choice is between accepting the chargeback and contesting it. Contest when you have evidence the bank will accept:

    • Proof of delivery with tracking that shows the address the customer gave.
    • Authentication such as 3D Secure. For many fraud disputes on authenticated payments, liability shifts to the card issuer.
    • Matching details like billing address, IP location and past orders from the same customer.
    • Clear terms the customer accepted, plus usage or login logs for digital goods and subscriptions.

    Without that evidence, contesting usually just adds time and any counter fee. Use the win-chance setting above to see where the line falls for your orders.

    How a chargeback unfolds

    1. Dispute The cardholder contacts their bank, usually within about 120 days.
    2. Chargeback The bank pulls the money back and your provider charges its fee.
    3. Your response You accept, or send evidence before the provider's deadline.
    4. Decision The issuing bank reviews the evidence and decides.
    5. Escalation Rarely, pre-arbitration or arbitration by the card network, with further fees.
    Network limits

    Visa and Mastercard chargeback thresholds

    Both networks run monitoring programs. Cross a threshold and your payment provider can face fees it usually passes on to you.

    Merchant monitoring thresholds, 2026
    ProgramWhat is countedRatioMinimum a month
    Visa VAMP (Excessive)Fraud reports + disputes ÷ settled card-not-present transactions1.5%*1,500 fraud + disputes
    Mastercard ECMChargebacks ÷ previous month's transactions1.5%100 chargebacks
    Mastercard HECMChargebacks ÷ previous month's transactions3%300 chargebacks

    * Visa lowered its merchant level from 2.2% to 1.5% on 1 April 2026 for the US, Canada, Europe and Asia Pacific. VAMP replaced Visa's separate dispute and fraud programs in April 2025. Rules and fees change, and your payment provider may act earlier, so confirm current limits with them.

    Prevention

    How to reduce chargebacks

    Use a recognisable descriptorMake the name on card statements match your brand, so customers don't dispute a charge they simply don't recognise.
    Make refunds easy to ask forShow a contact link and refund policy where customers look. A quick answer stops many disputes before they reach the bank.
    Turn on 3D SecureAuthenticating card-not-present payments reduces fraud and gives you stronger evidence if a dispute comes.
    Keep delivery proofShip with tracking, and keep order, login and download records for digital goods.
    Be clear about renewalsRemind subscribers before they are charged and make cancelling simple.
    Use pre-dispute alertsServices from Visa (Verifi) and Mastercard (Ethoca) let you refund a disputed payment before it becomes a chargeback.

    Seeing disputes from cards you don't expect? Use the BIN checker to see a card's issuing country and type, and compare it with the customer's address and IP location.

    FAQ

    Chargeback questions

    Can't find your answer? Our support team is happy to help.

    Contact support
    What is a chargeback?

    A chargeback is when a cardholder disputes a payment with their bank and the bank takes the money back from the merchant. The merchant can accept it or send evidence to challenge it, and the bank decides the outcome.

    What is the difference between a refund and a chargeback?

    A refund is the merchant returning money voluntarily. A chargeback is forced by the cardholder's bank. Chargebacks add a fee, take staff time, and count towards card network monitoring ratios. Refunds do not.

    How much is a chargeback fee?

    It depends on your payment provider and risk level. Fees of about $15 to $25 per dispute are common for low-risk merchants and can reach $100 for high-risk accounts. Stripe, for example, charges $15 per dispute in the US. Check your own fee schedule.

    Do I get the processing fee back when I refund?

    Usually not. Many providers, including Stripe and PayPal, keep the original processing fee when you refund a payment, which is why the calculator assumes the fee is lost unless you change that setting.

    What is a good chargeback ratio?

    As low as possible. Mastercard's first monitoring level starts at 1.5% with at least 100 chargebacks in a month, and Visa's merchant level is 1.5% of fraud and disputes from April 2026. Many payment providers start reviewing accounts well before those levels.

    Should I refund after a chargeback has been filed?

    Generally no. Once a dispute is open, a refund does not stop it, so you can end up paying twice. Respond through the dispute process instead, or accept the chargeback if you have no evidence.

    Can I win a chargeback?

    Yes, when you have clear evidence: proof of delivery, a matching billing address, 3D Secure authentication, signed terms or usage logs. Without evidence, contesting usually just adds staff time and any counter fee.

    How long can a customer file a chargeback?

    For most reasons it is around 120 days from the transaction or the expected delivery date, but the exact window depends on the card network and the dispute reason.

    More free tools

    Related payment tools

    We may use cookies or any other tracking technologies when you visit our website, including any other media form, mobile website, or mobile application related or connected to help customize the Site and improve your experience. We use cookies to keep this site working and to improve your experience.

    Learn More Accept